Does the new Excel PIVOTBY function mean the death of pivot tables?

This page has 0 threads | Add post

Blogs

Finding our blogs useful? Please consider helping us to share more!

Does the new Excel PIVOTBY function mean the death of pivot tables?
The new PIVOTBY function in Excel allows you to create a pivot table with a dynamic formula. Does this mean that the pivot table is redundant?

Posted by Andy Brown on 05 November 2024

In this blog

The old world: pivot tables
The new PIVOTBY function
Advantages of the PIVOTBY approach
Advantages of the Pivot Table approach
Conclusion

Is the pivot table redundant now that there's an Excel PIVOTBY function? This blog considers the advantages and disadvantages of each method of slicing and dicing data.

I haven't attempted to explain any of the syntax of the PIVOTBY function in this blog: for this see my colleague Andrew's excellent explanation of the syntax of the new Excel GROUPBY and PIVOTBY functions.

The old world: pivot tables

In Excel (and I'm hoping my readers know this!) you can create a pivot table to show data dynamically:

Creating a pivot table in old-style Excel.

This creates something looking like this:

Here we're filtering by film certificate, grouping by genre, showing the countries in the columns and showing the average run time for each film as data.

Here's what these choices look like:

The choices corresponding to the pivot table shown above.

The new PIVOTBY function

Here's the PIVOTBY version of this pivot table by contrast:

I haven't attempted any clever tricks (for that see my separate blog on creating dynamic pivot tables using the PIVOTBY function).

This uses a dynamic formula to fill as many cells as are needed.

Advantages of the PIVOTBY approach

It seems to me that the second method of pivoting data (using a function) has one big advantage - being a formula, it's dynamic. If you change one of the values in your underlying data:

Here we've switched to the (imaginary) director's cut of Zombieland, in which Bill Murray gets more than a cameo part, extending the length from 88 to 880 minutes ...

... then the data returned by the PIVOTBY function will automatically update:

... meaning that the average runtime for Comedy films has shot up (was Zombieland really a comedy?).

The other big advantage of using PIVOTBY to return pivoted data is that any other formula in your workbook can then reference this in a straightforward fashion (because the data is being returned by a normal formula its behaviour will be predictable).

Advantages of the Pivot Table approach

There are two obvious advantages of the pivot table approach:

Advantage	Notes
Flexibility	It's easy to add grouping fields, or swap rows or columns round.
Formatting	It's much easier to format the data returned by a pivot table.

Let's look at an example of each of these. For flexibility, suppose that you want to swap the genre and country round in our example. For a pivot table you can just drag and drop:

Swapping fields around could hardly be easier!

For a PIVOTBY function formua, by contrast, you need to edit the function arguments manually.

In addition to the obvious formatting tools shown above, pivot tables also allow you to add slicers and timelines to provide additional ways of filtering data.

On the formatting front, pivot tables have a huge array of tools to make it easy to format them, including pivot table styles. Here's just one example:

If you want to change the number format of every cell, you can choose this option with a single cell selected. With a PIVOTBY function you would have to select all of the cells returned from the formula first.

Conclusion

If you are creating a pivot table to present at a board meeting, it makes sense to continue to do this manually (since you'll then have far more control over the structure and formatting of your pivoted data). If on the other hand you are only pivoting data so that you can get at (and perhaps further manipulate) the aggregated data, it may make sense to use the new PIVOTBY function instead.

Some other pages relevant to the above blog include:

Excel classes

This blog has 0 threads

Add a new post

BLOGS BY TOPIC

BLOGS BY AUTHOR

The old world: pivot tables

The new PIVOTBY function

Advantages of the PIVOTBY approach

Advantages of the Pivot Table approach

Conclusion

Head office

London

Manchester